Ask Saint Latest Questions

Is Surrogacy Allowed in Islam?

allowislamislamicmuslimpermissionsurrogacy

You must login to add an answer.

Need An Account,

3 Answers

  1. Rushna shah
    Muslim Writer

    Surrogacy in Islam is a complex and debated issue among scholars. It is not explicitly mentioned in the Quran or Hadith, so opinions vary.Traditional Surrogacy (using the surrogate’s egg): Traditional surrogacy, where the surrogate is genetically related to the child, is generally considered haram (forbidden) in most Islamic interpretations because it can lead to complex issues of lineage and parentage.Gestational Surrogacy (using the intended mother’s egg): Gestational surrogacy, where the surrogate carries a child not genetically related to her, is also a subject of debate. Some scholars permit it under specific conditions, such as ensuring the legality of the contract, maintaining Islamic ethics, and safeguarding the rights and lineage of the child.Opinions on surrogacy can differ among Islamic scholars and schools of thought, so individuals considering surrogacy are advised to consult with knowledgeable scholars to ensure compliance with Islamic principles and local legal requirements.

      • 0
  3. Sultan Abu Muhammad Qureshi
    Muslim Writer
    This answer was improved

    What is Surrogacy?

    • Surrogacy is a reproductive arrangement in which a woman (the surrogate mother) carries and gives birth to a child on behalf of another person or couple (the intended parents). The surrogate mother may or may not be genetically related to the child.

    2. Is Surrogacy Halal in Islam?

    • The permissibility of surrogacy in Islam is a matter of debate among Islamic scholars.
    • Some scholars consider it impermissible due to concerns about lineage and biological ties.
    • Others may permit it under certain conditions, such as ensuring that the surrogate mother is a married and Muslim woman.
    • The acceptability of surrogacy can vary based on interpretations of Islamic law and local religious authorities.

    3. How Was Prophet Isa (Jesus) Born Without a Father According to Surah Maryam?

    • According to Islamic tradition, the birth of Prophet Isa (Jesus) without a human father is considered a miracle.
    • Surah Maryam (Chapter 19 of the Quran) narrates the story of the miraculous birth of Isa from Maryam (Mary).
    • Islamic belief holds that this miracle was a divine intervention and not a result of a natural human reproductive process.

    4. Opinion on Surrogacy (MY Perspective):

    • My opinion is that surrogacy is halal based on certain principles and my interpretation of Islamic law.
    • I draw an analogy between surrogacy and the concept of “Hurmat Musahirah” (issues related to breastfeeding) to support my perspective.
    • It’s important to recognize that Islamic jurisprudence allows for diverse opinions, and my perspective is one interpretation.

    5. Collaboration with Scholars:

    • As a scholar, it is advisable to engage in constructive dialogue and discussion with other scholars and religious authorities.
    • Collaborative discussion can help refine and deepen the understanding of complex issues in Islamic jurisprudence and consider various viewpoints.

    In summary, my perspective on surrogacy being permissible in Islam is based on my interpretation of certain Islamic principles, and it is important to acknowledge that this is one viewpoint among many within the broader field of Islamic jurisprudence. The permissibility of surrogacy remains a matter of debate among scholars and is subject to varying interpretations based on individual perspectives and local contexts.

      • 0
  4. Umar Mukhtar Habib
    Is Surrogacy Allowed in Islam?

    No, never, Islam does not allow surrogacy in any way, because surrogacy is renting a mother’s womb, which is gaining popularity in today’s world, and in this way, giving birth to a child by using someone else’s sperm by renting a womb is not legal in Islam.

      • 0